A partner mechanical garage calls: it has a front wing to repair, a bumper to replace, and a price already negotiated with its customer. For an auto body technician, accepting this subcontracting job “to keep the booth busy” can seem better than leaving a slot empty. But first, calculate the full cost, then compare the resulting margin rate with a threshold set for your workshop.

There is no universal margin rate that makes every job worthwhile. Your threshold depends on your costs, available capacity, and the other work you could take on in the same time slot. Here is a recalculable method using clearly identified working assumptions.

How to cost a subcontracting job line by line

Hypothetical working assumption: your auto body shop receives a front-wing repair and bumper replacement from a partner mechanical garage. The price offered by the commissioning garage is 1,500 € excl. VAT.

Job itemHypothetical calculationCost
Front wingPart210 € excl. VAT
BumperPart150 € excl. VAT
FastenersSet20 € excl. VAT
Paint productsBase 42 € + clear coat 24 € + primer 16 € + thinner 13 €95 € excl. VAT
ConsumablesAbrasives 18 € + masking 12 € + protection 5 €35 € excl. VAT
Bodywork labour4 h × 28 €112 €
Paint labour3.5 h × 28 €98 €
Job administration0.75 h × 28 €21 €
Paint-booth energyAmount allocated to the job18 € excl. VAT
Total direct cost759 € excl. VAT

The 28 € hourly labour cost is also a working assumption. It is calculated as follows: gross monthly salary of 2,100 € ÷ 105 productive hours = 20 € per hour; hypothetical employer contributions of 840 € ÷ 105 hours = 8 € per hour. The loaded hourly cost used here is therefore 28 €. Salaries and employer contributions are not subject to VAT, so they are shown without a VAT label.

The 105 monthly productive hours, salary, employer contributions, and parts and product costs above are not market averages; they are working assumptions to demonstrate the method. Replace them with your own figures. For context on actual market prices, INSEE series 000849401 reports an average retail price of 127.33 € incl. VAT for one hour of auto body labour in metropolitan France in September 2026. This public price incl. VAT is neither a subcontracting contract rate nor a cost price. SRA and FFC statistical publications provide hourly-rate indices, not prices in euros. Sources are listed at the end of the article.

Illustrated auto body repair components, paint supplies, and cost elements arranged around a calculator

Margin rate and margin on sales for this job

A direct cost of 759 € excl. VAT is not enough to determine the job’s result: you must also allocate its share of the workshop’s fixed costs. In this hypothetical example, monthly fixed costs are: rent 2,600 € excl. VAT; insurance 450 € excl. VAT; equipment and depreciation 850 € excl. VAT; software and telecommunications 250 € excl. VAT; fixed share of energy costs 500 € excl. VAT; other workshop fixed costs 650 € excl. VAT; total 5,300 € excl. VAT.

With 105 productive hours per month, the fixed cost allocated per productive hour is 5,300 € excl. VAT ÷ 105 h = 50.48 €. The job uses 7.5 productive bodywork and paint hours. Its allocated share of fixed costs is therefore 7.5 × 5,300 € ÷ 105 = 378.57 €.

The estimated full cost is 759 € + 378.57 € = 1,137.57 €. At the offered price of 1,500 € excl. VAT, the margin in euros is 1,500 € − 1,137.57 € = 362.43 €.

  • Margin rate = margin ÷ full cost = 362.43 € ÷ 1,137.57 € = 31.9 %.
  • Margin on sales = margin ÷ selling price = 362.43 € ÷ 1,500 € = 24.2 %.

These two rates answer different questions: the margin rate compares the result with the cost; margin on sales compares it with the invoiced price.

The refusal threshold: what is the minimum margin rate for saying no?

In this example, the workshop adopts a hypothetical management rule: refuse or renegotiate any job that does not achieve a 20 % margin rate on full cost. This threshold is neither a professional standard nor a market average; it is an internal target to adapt to your business.

To reach this threshold, the minimum price is 1,137.57 € × 1.20 = 1,365.08 € excl. VAT. Below this price, the margin falls short of the chosen target. Above it, the job meets this criterion, provided the estimated time is realistic and any rework risks have been assessed.

You must also distinguish full-cost calculation from a short-term decision. If you refuse the job, the workshop’s 5,300 € excl. VAT in monthly fixed costs remain due. At the offered price, after direct costs, 1,500 € − 759 € = 741 € remains to cover those fixed costs. The 378.57 € allocated to the job is an accounting allocation of fixed expenses: you still pay it if you decline the job. After this allocation, 362.43 € is the estimated margin on full cost.

Why an available time slot is not enough to justify accepting

An empty slot does not have the same value as a slot that could be used for a more profitable job. Another working assumption: a direct job of the same duration and full cost could be sold for 1,700 € excl. VAT. Its estimated margin would be 1,700 € − 1,137.57 € = 562.43 €. Compared with the subcontracted job’s 362.43 €, the difference is 200 € for the same 7.5 productive hours.

That 200 € difference is the opportunity cost if the direct job is genuinely available and can be done instead. If there is no other demand for that time slot, the comparison changes: the subcontracting job may help cover part of the fixed costs, as long as it covers its direct costs, pays for the time used, and meets quality requirements.

Two auto body workshop bays illustrate a subcontracting job and a possible alternative job, with abstract coins and a balance scale

What is the effect of a 10 % discount for the commissioning garage?

A hypothetical 10 % discount reduces the price from 1,500 € excl. VAT to 1,350 € excl. VAT. The estimated full cost remains 1,137.57 €.

The margin becomes 1,350 € − 1,137.57 € = 212.43 €. The margin rate falls to 18.7 % and margin on sales to 15.7 %. The job therefore falls below the 20 % management threshold used in this example. To meet that threshold, the price must remain at least 1,365.08 € excl. VAT: the maximum discount is about 9 %, not 10 %.

These results change as soon as actual time, parts, products, or fixed costs differ. Recalculate both rates whenever an item changes. ProCalc.app can help you check margin calculations quickly. It is a one-time purchase, with no subscription and no data collection.

How to negotiate or decline professionally

SituationPossible decision
The price meets your threshold and the time required is controlledAccept, specifying the scope, supplied parts, and rework conditions.
The price is slightly below the thresholdOffer a revised price or adjust the scope: parts, transport, dismantling, or additional operations.
The price is below the threshold and the slot could be used for a more profitable jobDecline politely and explain that the price does not cover your full cost.
Costs or time are uncertainAsk for the missing information and confirm the final price after inspecting the vehicle.

You could reply to the commissioning garage: “Thank you for your offer. After costing the parts, bodywork and paint time, and workshop expenses, we cannot carry out this job at that price. We can offer it at [recalculated price] € excl. VAT, or review the scope of the work together.”

Quick tip: Always calculate direct cost and full cost separately. Then compare the offered price with your internal threshold and check whether the time slot could be used for another job. To explore how to calculate a workshop hourly rate, see our article on auto repair garage hourly rates and margin rates on parts in 2026.

Frequently asked questions

What minimum margin rate should you set for a subcontracted bodywork job?

There is no threshold that applies to every workshop. In this article’s example, 20 % is a hypothetical management target: the price must reach 1,365.08 € excl. VAT to cover the estimated full cost of 1,137.57 € and achieve that margin.

How do you calculate the margin rate for an auto body job?

Subtract the job’s full cost from its selling price, then divide that margin by the full cost. Here: (1,500 € − 1,137.57 €) ÷ 1,137.57 € = 31.9 %.

What is the difference between margin rate and margin on sales?

The margin rate compares the margin with the cost; margin on sales compares it with the selling price. For this article’s hypothetical job, the rates are 31.9 % and 24.2 %, respectively.

What should you include in the cost of a subcontracting job?

List the parts, paint products, consumables, bodywork time, paint time, job administration, and paint-booth energy. Then add the share of fixed costs allocated to the productive hours used.

Can a 10 % discount make a job unprofitable?

Yes. In the example, a 10 % discount lowers the margin rate from 31.9 % to 18.7 %. The job remains above its estimated full cost, but falls below the example’s 20 % management target.

Should you accept a subcontracting job just to keep the booth busy?

Not automatically. Check direct costs, full cost, and whether a more profitable job could be done in the same time slot. If there is no other demand, the job may help cover fixed costs, but its price must at least cover direct costs and the time used.

Sources consulted on 2 November 2026: INSEE series 000849401, reporting an average retail price of 127.33 € incl. VAT for one hour of auto body labour in metropolitan France in September 2026; SRA Statistical Communication, third quarter 2025; FFC Statistical Communication, third quarter 2025. The INSEE figure is a public price incl. VAT, not a subcontracting contract rate or a cost price. SRA figures are indices, not prices in euros. All other amounts in the example are working assumptions.

Leave a comment

Sign in to post your comment or sign-up if you don't have any account.